What If I’m at Fault in a South Carolina Car Wreck? Insurance, Lawsuits, and Your Assets
A few times a year, someone asks me a version of the same question: “I caused a wreck. Should I hire my own lawyer to keep the other person from going after my assets?”
The first step is always to notify your insurance carrier. For a claim covered by your liability policy, the carrier has the right to control settlement negotiations and the obligation to provide your defense. Those responsibilities begin when a claim is made against you, not just when someone files a lawsuit.
You also do not need to cause a catastrophic injury for your insurance limits to become an issue. A claim involving a single emergency room visit may approach or exceed minimum bodily injury limits when medical expenses, pain and suffering, lost wages, and other damages are considered. Depending on the circumstances of the wreck, punitive damages may also be available.
Here is what South Carolina drivers should understand about their insurer’s responsibilities and their own potential exposure.
Your insurance carrier controls negotiations and litigation
When someone makes a covered claim against you, your liability carrier handles the investigation, negotiations, and defense. If a lawsuit is filed, it hires and pays the lawyer who represents you.
This is the carrier’s contractual right and responsibility. You are not simply choosing to let it take over. Under the policy, the carrier has authority to negotiate and settle the claim, subject to its obligation to act in good faith.
In Sentry Select Insurance Co. v. Maybank Law Firm, LLC, 426 S.C. 154, 157–58, 826 S.E.2d 270, 271–72 (2019), the South Carolina Supreme Court explained the insurer’s defense obligation and settlement authority. The Court also emphasized that the lawyer hired to defend you owes professional duties to you. The insurance company’s payment of the bill does not change that relationship. sccourts.org
These obligations concern claims covered by the policy. Whether coverage exists can itself become a separate dispute.
Your carrier must reasonably consider settlement within your policy limits
Control over settlement comes with a duty to protect your interests.
South Carolina’s longstanding rule is that a liability insurer must settle a covered claim within policy limits when doing so is reasonable. In Tyger River Pine Co. v. Maryland Casualty Co., 170 S.C. 286, 294, 170 S.E. 346, 349 (1933), the Supreme Court recognized the insurer’s duty to settle when that is the reasonable thing to do. www.scbar.org
The Court reaffirmed that principle in Doe v. South Carolina Medical Malpractice Liability Joint Underwriting Association, 347 S.C. 642, 649, 557 S.E.2d 670, 674 (2001). An insurer that unreasonably fails to settle a covered claim within its limits can become responsible for the resulting excess judgment. www.sccourts.org
South Carolina Code § 38-59-20 also addresses improper claims practices, including failure to make good-faith efforts to settle fairly when liability is reasonably clear. That statute allows regulatory enforcement when its requirements are met. The insured’s right to pursue a bad-faith lawsuit comes from a separate body of court decisions. www.scstatehouse.gov
A carrier does not have to pay its limits automatically whenever someone demands them. It must reasonably evaluate the evidence, the potential damages, and the opportunity to resolve the claim while protecting you.
Will hiring a private lawyer change who controls the claim?
Hiring another lawyer does not transfer settlement authority from your carrier to that lawyer.
For an ordinary covered claim, your insurer is already responsible for handling negotiations and providing a defense. A privately retained lawyer cannot make the carrier offer more money, authorize payment of its limits, or guarantee that it will settle.
That is why hiring a second lawyer simply because you have assets or receive a demand above your limits may accomplish little beyond adding legal fees. Those circumstances do not change who controls the carrier’s settlement decisions.
You can communicate directly with your carrier and the lawyer assigned to defend you. Ask questions, provide relevant information, and put your request for a reasonable settlement within policy limits in writing.
A dispute over whether your carrier must provide coverage is a different issue from hiring another lawyer to influence negotiations in a covered claim.
Can the injured person collect from your personal assets?
Potentially, yes. Your insurance limits do not cap the damages a jury can award against you.
Suppose one injured person obtains a $250,000 judgment, your applicable liability insurance pays $50,000, and no other applicable insurance or settlement protection exists. You could face collection efforts for the remaining $200,000.
The injured person, now a judgment creditor, can use South Carolina’s judgment-enforcement procedures to pursue assets legally available for collection.
That does not mean every possession or account is exposed. South Carolina Code § 15-41-30 protects certain property. Whether a particular asset can be reached depends on ownership, equity, applicable exemptions, and other circumstances. scstatehouse.gov
What are South Carolina’s minimum liability limits?
Under South Carolina Code § 38-77-140, the minimum automobile liability limits are:
- $25,000 for bodily injury to one person.
- $50,000 total for bodily injury to multiple people in one accident.
- $25,000 for property damage in one accident.
The $50,000 accident limit does not mean one injured person has $50,000 available under a minimum-limits bodily injury policy. The per-person limit still applies. www.scstatehouse.gov
Bodily injury and property damage have separate limits, but both coverages can be available to pay punitive damages. Punitive damages punish qualifying misconduct, such as reckless driving, rather than simply reimbursing medical bills or repair expenses.
In Government Employees Insurance Co. v. Poole, 424 S.C. 1, 817 S.E.2d 283 (2018), the Supreme Court held that South Carolina law does not require punitive damages to be divided proportionally between bodily injury and property damage coverage. The Court also discussed an earlier federal decision allowing punitive damages to be recovered from the at-fault driver’s property damage liability coverage.
The available coverage still depends on the policy and the facts. Punitive damages are not available merely because an accident happened, and this does not make the two limits interchangeable for every type of loss. sccourts.org
UIM coverage is optional, and it is not your extra liability insurance
Underinsured motorist coverage, commonly called UIM, protects an insured injured by someone whose liability insurance is insufficient.
South Carolina law requires insurers to offer UIM coverage, but drivers are not required to purchase it. See South Carolina Code § 38-77-160.
Your own UIM coverage does not function as additional liability insurance for damages you owe because you caused a wreck. scstatehouse.gov
The injured person may have UIM coverage, but you should not simply add their UIM limits to your liability limits and assume that total determines whether your personal assets are exposed.
In Estate of Rattenni v. Grainger, 298 S.C. 276, 379 S.E.2d 890 (1989), the injured person’s estate received $300,000 in UIM benefits before trial. A jury later awarded $800,000 in damages.
The at-fault driver asked to deduct the UIM payment from the award. The Supreme Court refused. The injured person’s own insurance did not reduce the wrongdoer’s liability. law.justia.com
A settlement can protect your assets while a UIM case continues
An injured person may agree not to pursue the driver’s personal assets while continuing to seek UIM benefits.
That protection may come through a release or a covenant not to execute, which is a promise limiting the injured person’s right to collect against the driver personally.
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. v. Tate, 313 S.C. 444, 438 S.E.2d 266 (Ct. App. 1993), describes a settlement that protected the at-fault driver’s personal assets while the litigation involving UIM benefits continued.
The driver’s name remained in the lawsuit, but the agreement prohibited personal collection. The settlement’s terms, rather than the name appearing on the lawsuit, determined that protection. law.justia.com
What if your carrier could have settled within your limits but refused?
If your carrier unreasonably fails to settle a covered claim within policy limits and that failure causes you harm, you may have a bad-faith claim against it.
A successful claim can make the carrier responsible for the excess judgment that otherwise would have exposed you personally. See Doe, 347 S.C. at 649, 557 S.E.2d at 674. www.sccourts.org
The history behind this rule is surprisingly concrete. In the 1933 Tyger River case, a lumber company had $5,000 in insurance but faced a $7,000 judgment after an employee was injured. Its insurer declined an opportunity to settle the judgment for the policy limits. The company later recovered its additional loss from the insurer. www.scbar.org
A bad-faith claim is not automatic because a demand was rejected or a jury awarded more than the coverage. The carrier’s conduct, the opportunity to settle, and the resulting harm must be evaluated. A possible future bad-faith claim also does not automatically stop collection of the underlying judgment.
Can you bring a bad-faith claim against the injured person’s UIM carrier?
Ordinarily, you cannot bring your own bad-faith claim against the injured person’s UIM insurer simply because it declined to settle.
That insurer’s obligations run to its insured. It does not owe you those same obligations merely because you are the at-fault driver.
South Carolina generally does not extend insurance bad-faith claims to people outside the insurance relationship. See Kleckley v. Northwestern National Casualty Co., 338 S.C. 131, 134–36, 526 S.E.2d 218, 219–20 (2000). www.sccourts.org
The injured person may have a bad-faith claim against their own UIM carrier in appropriate circumstances. But that carrier can contest a disputed claim and is not required to pay its limits automatically. The Supreme Court addressed those distinctions in Hood v. United Services Auto Association, Opinion No. 28249 (S.C. Jan. 8, 2025). www.sccourts.org
Does having substantial assets require you to carry higher limits?
South Carolina’s minimum insurance requirements do not increase with your net worth.
The statutory definition of an underinsured vehicle compares liability coverage with the injured insured’s damages, not the at-fault driver’s assets. See South Carolina Code § 38-77-30(15). scstatehouse.gov
Imagine a billionaire carrying only minimum liability coverage. Meeting the minimum requirement would not protect that person’s wealth from a larger judgment. However, carrying low limits relative to personal assets does not, by itself, create a special legal status called “willfully underinsured.”
Before a wreck occurs, review your liability limits and ask your agent about umbrella coverage. Buying the legal minimum and buying enough protection for your circumstances are different decisions.
What should you do after an at-fault wreck?
- Notify your carrier promptly.
- Identify every potentially applicable policy, including umbrella or employer coverage.
- Send your carrier every demand, letter, and lawsuit document you receive.
- Cooperate with the investigation and the lawyer assigned to defend you.
- Ask your carrier to explain the available limits and any coverage concerns.
- Request in writing that your carrier pursue a reasonable settlement within policy limits that protects you from personal liability. Keep a copy.
- Ask whether any proposed settlement includes a release or an enforceable agreement protecting your personal assets.
A written request could say:
Please make every reasonable effort to resolve this claim within my available policy limits and obtain a release or other agreement protecting me from personal liability. Please keep me informed of settlement demands, opportunities to settle within my limits, and any potential exposure beyond my coverage.
Your carrier has the right to control a covered claim, and that control comes with responsibilities. Notify it, cooperate, document your request for a reasonable settlement, and understand what protection any agreement actually provides.
This article provides general information about South Carolina law. It is not legal advice for a particular claim and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Categories
Bicycle Accidents Boating Accidents Bus Accidents Car Accidents Child Injuries Drunk Driving And Other Punitive Issues Food Poisoning Get To Know Us Head Injuries Insurance Motorcycle Accidents Pedestrian Accidents Personal Injury Premises Liability Prescription Drug Overdose Products Liability Property Damage Slip and Fall Accidents Traumatic Brain Injury Trucking Accidents Wrongful Death